Today, I’m excited to share my favorite classic cocktail—the Bourbon Old Fashioned. The Old Fashioned has been my go-to drink for years, and learning to make the perfect one at home has been such a rewarding experience. You’re definitely going to want to learn this recipe, as the Old Fashioned is arguably the most popular bourbon cocktail out there. It’s sweet, strong, and perfectly simple—a true classic!
In this blog post, I will guide you through the traditional recipe, along with some time-saving tricks and tips to help you craft the perfect Old Fashioned right in your own kitchen. Whether you’re hosting a gathering or simply enjoying a quiet evening at home, mastering this cocktail will elevate your mixology skills and impress your guests. Let’s dive in!
Old Fashioned Ingredients
To craft the perfect Old Fashioned, you’ll need a few key ingredients that come together to create this timeless cocktail. Here’s what you’ll need:
Bourbon: Choose a high-quality bourbon or rye whiskey—something you would enjoy sipping on its own. The quality of the spirit is crucial, as it forms the base of your cocktail.
Angostura Bitters: This classic cocktail bitter adds depth and complexity to your drink. You can easily find Angostura bitters on Amazon or at your local liquor store.
Sugar: For the traditional recipe, you will need granulated sugar. If you want to save some time, you can use simple syrup instead of sugar and water. This can make the mixing process a bit quicker and easier.
Water: A splash of water is necessary to help dissolve the sugar and enhance the flavors.
Orange Twist: This garnish adds a lovely citrus aroma and a touch of brightness to your cocktail.
Cherries: While not part of the traditional recipe, many people enjoy adding two cherries to their Old Fashioned. This is optional, but it can add a nice touch of sweetness.
With these ingredients on hand, you’re well on your way to making a delicious Old Fashioned that’s sure to impress!
History of an Old Fashioned
The Old Fashioned cocktail is one of the first officially recorded cocktails, boasting over 200 years of history and counting. It was invented during a time when bartenders had yet to start adding fancy embellishments to their drinks. The name “Old Fashioned” originated from patrons who preferred their cocktails simple and traditional, opting for a straightforward mix of spirits, sugar, and bitters.
The Origins of the Old Fashioned
The roots of the Old Fashioned can be traced back to the early 19th century. The first known mention of the cocktail appeared in the 1806 issue of The Balance and Columbian Repository, where it was described as a “whiskey cocktail.” This early version consisted of a spirit (typically whiskey), sugar, water, and bitters, which are the foundational elements of what we now recognize as the Old Fashioned.
As the cocktail culture evolved, so did the Old Fashioned. By the late 1800s, the drink had gained popularity in bars across the United States, particularly in cities like New Orleans and Chicago. It became a staple among the upper class, often enjoyed in elegant settings. The simplicity of the Old Fashioned appealed to those who appreciated the quality of the ingredients rather than the complexity of the preparation.
A Classic Never Goes Out of Style
This classic drink has stood the test of time, proving that some things never go out of style. In recent years, new generations of cocktail enthusiasts (like me!) have rediscovered the Old Fashioned, thanks in part to popular television shows like Mad Men, which have helped ensure its legacy will continue. The show’s portrayal of the 1960s advertising world, complete with its stylish characters enjoying Old Fashioneds, sparked a renewed interest in classic cocktails.
Moreover, the craft cocktail movement has played a significant role in the Old Fashioned’s resurgence. Bartenders and mixologists have embraced the drink, experimenting with different types of bitters, sweeteners, and even variations in the base spirit. This creativity has allowed the Old Fashioned to evolve while still honoring its traditional roots.
The Old Fashioned Today
Today, the Old Fashioned remains a symbol of sophistication and simplicity, making it a beloved choice for both seasoned cocktail drinkers and newcomers alike. It’s often served in a short, round glass known as an Old Fashioned glass or rocks glass, which allows the drinker to appreciate the cocktail’s rich color and garnishes.
The drink is typically garnished with an orange twist and sometimes a cherry, adding a touch of brightness and sweetness. Many enthusiasts enjoy experimenting with different types of whiskey, such as bourbon or rye, to create their perfect version of the Old Fashioned.
As you enjoy your Old Fashioned, you’re not just sipping a drink; you’re partaking in a rich history that celebrates the art of mixology and the timeless appeal of a well-crafted cocktail. Whether you’re enjoying it at a trendy bar or crafting it at home, the Old Fashioned invites you to savor the moment and appreciate the craftsmanship behind this iconic drink.
So, the next time you raise your glass, remember that you’re indulging in a cocktail that has delighted palates for centuries, and continue to explore the variations and nuances that make the Old Fashioned a true classic in the world of cocktails.
How to Mix an Old Fashioned?
Crafting the perfect Old Fashioned is a delightful process that allows you to appreciate the simplicity and elegance of this classic cocktail. Follow these steps to mix your own Old Fashioned at home:
Prepare the Mixing Glass: Begin by pouring your sugar into a cocktail mixing glass. You can use granulated sugar for the traditional recipe or opt for simple syrup if you prefer a quicker method.
Add Bitters: Add three dashes of Angostura bitters directly to the sugar. The bitters are essential for adding depth and complexity to the drink.
Incorporate Water: Add a splash of water to the mixture. This helps dissolve the sugar and meld the flavors together.
Mix Until Dissolved: Using a bar spoon, mix by hand until the sugar has completely dissolved. This step is crucial for ensuring a smooth cocktail without any gritty texture.
Add Ice: Fill the mixing glass with ice. Using large ice cubes is ideal, as they melt more slowly and help maintain the drink’s temperature without diluting it too quickly.
Pour the Bourbon: Pour your chosen bourbon over the ice. The quality of the bourbon is key, so choose one that you enjoy sipping on its own.7. Stir to Chill: Continue stirring the mixture until the drink is well mixed and chilled. This usually takes about 20-30 seconds.
Strain into a Glass: Strain the mixture into a rock glass over an oversized ice cube. The large cube will keep your drink cold while minimizing dilution.
Express the Orange Peel: To add a burst of citrus aroma, express the oil of an orange peel over the top of the glass. You do this by squeezing and folding the skin of the orange peel, releasing the essential oils. You should smell a strong citrus scent as the oils are released.
Garnish: Finally, garnish your drink with the orange peel. You can place it on the rim of the glass or drop it into the drink for added flavor.
Now that you’ve mixed your Old Fashioned, take a moment to appreciate the craftsmanship that went into creating this classic cocktail. Savor the rich flavors and enjoy the experience of sipping a drink that has stood the test of time. Whether you’re enjoying it solo or sharing it with friends, the Old Fashioned is sure to impress!
Best Bourbon for an Old Fashioned
When it comes to crafting the perfect Old Fashioned, the choice of bourbon is crucial. This drink is very spirit-forward, so the quality of the bourbon you choose will significantly impact the flavor of your cocktail. You could spend hours reading opinions on the best bourbon for an Old Fashioned, but as a general rule, you should select a whiskey that you would enjoy sipping straight.
I love to collect local bourbons and whiskeys in every variety, and it’s a fun journey to create your own collection. That said, for the purposes of this blog post, I’m focusing on brands that are easily available and widely recognized for their quality.
Recommended Bourbons for Your Old Fashioned
Maker’s Mark
Why It’s Great: I chose this bourbon because it’s high quality and available at almost every liquor store.
Tasting Notes: Maker’s Mark has a slightly sweet profile, making it perfect for an Old Fashioned. Its smoothness complements the other ingredients beautifully.
Four Roses Single Barrel
Why It’s Great: Another popular option that is easy to find in stores, Four Roses Single Barrel is known for its rich flavor.
Tasting Notes: This high-proof bourbon offers a smooth flavor with a hint of spice, making it a fantastic choice for those who enjoy a bolder cocktail.
Old Granddad Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
Why It’s Great: Old Granddad is distilled with a high percentage of rye, which adds a unique character to the bourbon.
Tasting Notes: Its flavor is slightly spicy, with notes of cinnamon and cloves, which can enhance the complexity of your Old Fashioned.
Bulleit Bourbon
Why It’s Great: I chose Bulleit because it’s broadly available and well-regarded among bourbon enthusiasts.
Tasting Notes: This bourbon has slightly fruity and light flavor notes, making it a refreshing option for an Old Fashioned.
George Dickel Rye Whiskey
Why It’s Great: I wanted to include a rye whiskey since a Rye Old Fashioned is one of the most popular variations of this classic cocktail.
Tasting Notes: George Dickel Rye offers a spicier profile compared to traditional bourbon, which can add an exciting twist to your Old Fashioned.
Quick and Easy Tips
Make an Old Fashioned Mix
The quickest way to whip up a great-tasting Old Fashioned at home is to prepare an Old Fashioned Mix. Once you have this mix ready, you can create cocktails with zero prep whenever the mood strikes. This mix typically includes sugar, bitters, and a splash of water, allowing you to skip the individual steps when you’re ready to enjoy a drink.
Use Simple Syrup
Save time by using simple syrup instead of granulated sugar and water from the original recipe. Simple syrup is easier to mix and dissolves quickly, ensuring a smooth cocktail. This is especially handy if you prefer a sweeter cocktail, similar to what many restaurants serve. Using simple syrup is the easiest way to add a touch more sweetness to your drink without the hassle.
Batch for Dinner Parties
If you’re preparing for a dinner party, consider batching the entire drink ahead of time. You can mix up a larger quantity of Old Fashioneds and simply pour them into glasses with oversized ice cubes when it’s time to serve. This method is particularly useful for serving a group, as the original recipe can be a bit time-consuming when making multiple cocktails.
Pre-Mix Ingredients
If you want to save even more time, you can pre-mix the sugar, bitters, and water in a small container. When you’re ready to make your Old Fashioned, just add the bourbon and ice, stir, and serve. This way, you have everything ready to go, making the process much quicker.
Keep Ingredients Handy
Ensure that all your ingredients are easily accessible and organized. Having your bourbon, bitters, sugar, and garnishes within reach will streamline the cocktail-making process. This small step can make a big difference when you’re in the mood for a quick drink.
Variations of the Old Fashioned Cocktail
While the classic Old Fashioned is a beloved cocktail in its own right, there are many delicious spins on this timeless drink. Here are a few popular variations, each offering a unique twist by simply swapping out one ingredient.
Rye Old Fashioned
What Makes It Different: This variation uses rye whiskey instead of bourbon, resulting in a slightly less sweet and spicier flavor profile.
Why You’ll Love It: The spiciness of rye adds complexity to the drink, making it a great option for those who enjoy a bolder taste.
Brandy Old Fashioned (Wisconsin Old Fashioned)
What Makes It Different: In this recipe, brandy replaces bourbon, and the drink is often topped with lemon-lime soda, making it much sweeter than the classic version.
Why You’ll Love It: This variation is particularly popular in Wisconsin and offers a refreshing twist, perfect for those who prefer a sweeter cocktail with a fruity finish.
Pumpkin Spice Old Fashioned
What Makes It Different: By using pumpkin spice syrup instead of simple syrup, you can create a festive variation that’s perfect for fall.
Why You’ll Love It: This seasonal twist adds warm, cozy flavors of cinnamon and nutmeg, making it a delightful choice for autumn gatherings or holiday celebrations.
Irish Old Fashioned
What Makes It Different: This version swaps bourbon for Jameson Irish Whiskey, giving the cocktail a smooth and slightly different flavor profile.
Why You’ll Love It: The Irish whiskey adds a unique character to the drink, making it a great option for fans of whiskey who want to try something new.
Peanut Butter Old Fashioned
What Makes It Different: In this fun variation, Screwball peanut butter whiskey is used in place of bourbon, introducing a creamy, nutty flavor.
Why You’ll Love It: This playful twist is perfect for those who enjoy the combination of sweet and savory, making it a unique and memorable cocktail experience.
Should I Put Cherries in My Old Fashioned?
The classic Old Fashioned recipe does not include cherries, but as someone who has ordered this drink at dozens of restaurants, I can confidently say that it is served with cherries at least 75% of the time. Bottom line—if it’s good enough for Don Draper, it’s good enough for me!
Personal Preference
Personally, I love the addition of cherries and welcome them in my drink! They add a touch of sweetness and a pop of color, enhancing the overall presentation and flavor profile of the Old Fashioned. If you enjoy a hint of sweetness, adding cherries can be a delightful twist.
Recommended Cherries
If you decide to add cherries to your Old Fashioned, I suggest using Luxardo Maraschino Cherries. These dark candied cherries are rich, decadent, and far superior to the typical bright red maraschino cherries you might find in a grocery store. Their complex flavor complements the bourbon beautifully, making them an excellent choice for this classic cocktail.
Storage Tips
Once you open the jar of Luxardo cherries, be sure to store them in your fridge. They can last for quite a while, and you can use them in many classic cocktail recipes, such as Manhattan or even a Whiskey Sour. Having a jar of these cherries in hand can elevate your cocktail game and impress your guests.
